Homemade Butter Chicken – The Ultimate Recipe Guide

Introduction to Homemade Butter Chicken

Homemade Butter Chicken, also known as Murgh Makhani, is one of the most beloved Indian dishes worldwide. Its rich, creamy tomato-based sauce combined with tender chicken pieces creates a comforting meal that you can enjoy with rice, naan, or paratha. While restaurants often get all the attention for this classic dish, making butter chicken at home allows you to control the ingredients, adjust the spice levels, and create a healthier, more flavorful version. Plus, nothing beats the satisfaction of preparing this iconic curry from scratch in your own kitchen.

Butter chicken has its roots in Delhi, India, where it was first created in the 1950s. Since then, it has evolved into a global favorite that fits perfectly into family dinners, festive occasions, or even cozy weeknights. The best part? With the right guidance, even beginners can master this dish at home.

If you’re ready to learn the secrets behind tender chicken, creamy sauces, and the perfect spice balance, this detailed guide will walk you through every step. From picking ingredients to making your own spice mix, you’ll soon discover why homemade butter chicken is always a winning choice. For more Indian-inspired family meals, don’t miss our collection of flavorful recipes.

Introduction to Homemade Butter Chicken

The history and origin of butter chicken

Butter chicken, or Murgh Makhani, was invented by accident in the kitchens of the famous Moti Mahal restaurant in Delhi. The chefs found a way to use leftover tandoori chicken by simmering it in a tomato-based sauce enriched with cream and butter. This innovation quickly became a sensation, giving birth to one of the most iconic dishes in Indian cuisine. Its popularity grew not just in India but across the globe, especially in countries like the USA, UK, and Canada, where Indian food is a household favorite.

Why homemade butter chicken is better than takeout

While restaurant butter chicken is delicious, homemade versions have several advantages. First, you control the quality of ingredients—choosing fresh chicken, real cream, and high-quality spices ensures a healthier meal. Second, you can adjust the spice levels to suit your taste, whether you prefer it mild, medium, or extra spicy. Lastly, making it at home is often more affordable and provides the joy of cooking something special for your loved ones. Homemade butter chicken also avoids unnecessary additives, food coloring, or excessive oil often used in takeout versions.

Essential Ingredients for Homemade Butter Chicken

Classic spices and aromatics you need

The secret to authentic homemade butter chicken lies in its spice blend. Unlike other curries that may rely on heavy chili heat, butter chicken balances mild spices with creamy richness. Some of the most essential spices include:

• Cumin – adds an earthy, smoky depth.
• Coriander powder – brings a citrusy, slightly sweet note.
• Turmeric – provides a golden color and subtle warmth.
• Garam masala – the heart of Indian curries, blending cardamom, cinnamon, and cloves.
• Red chili powder or paprika – for heat and color (adjust to taste).
• Fenugreek leaves (Kasuri methi) – a must-have for restaurant-style aroma.

Along with these spices, aromatics like fresh garlic, ginger, and onions create the base of the sauce. When sautéed in butter, they release an irresistible fragrance that defines the dish.

Fresh vs store-bought ingredients

When it comes to butter chicken, freshness makes a huge difference. Fresh cream instead of packaged alternatives adds a velvety texture, while ripe tomatoes give the sauce a natural sweetness that canned varieties can’t match. For convenience, you can use store-bought garam masala or tomato purée, but grinding whole spices or blending fresh tomatoes at home elevates the taste dramatically.

Here’s a simple comparison:

Ingredient	Fresh Version	Store-bought Version	Best Choice
Tomatoes	Ripe, blended	Tomato purée/canned	Fresh
Garlic & Ginger	Fresh paste at home	Bottled paste	Fresh
Cream	Heavy fresh cream	Packaged tetra-pack	Fresh
Spices	Whole, ground at home	Pre-ground jars	Whole

So, if you want your homemade butter chicken to truly shine, prioritize fresh, high-quality ingredients wherever possible. And if you’re looking for other tips on choosing the right ingredients for family meals, check out our ingredient selection guide.

Preparing the Chicken Perfectly

Choosing the right chicken cuts for butter chicken

One of the most important steps in making homemade butter chicken is selecting the right cut of chicken. Traditionally, boneless chicken thighs are preferred because they stay moist and tender even after simmering in the sauce. Their natural fat content enhances the richness of the dish.

That said, chicken breast can also be used if you prefer lean meat. However, breasts tend to dry out faster, so they require careful marination and shorter cooking times. A good rule of thumb: if you want the most authentic restaurant-style butter chicken, go for chicken thighs. If you’re aiming for a lighter, healthier version, chicken breasts work just fine with the right techniques.

Marination tips for tenderness and flavor

Marination is what separates average chicken curry from irresistible homemade butter chicken. The secret lies in a yogurt-based marinade, which both tenderizes the meat and infuses it with flavor.

A typical butter chicken marinade includes:

• Yogurt (Greek or plain)
• Lemon juice
• Ginger-garlic paste
• Red chili powder or paprika
• Turmeric
• Salt
• A drizzle of oil

For best results, marinate the chicken for at least 2 hours, though overnight marination will give you the juiciest, most flavorful results. Once marinated, the chicken is usually grilled, baked, or pan-fried before being added to the sauce. This extra step locks in smoky flavors and prevents the chicken from becoming rubbery when simmered in the butter sauce.

If you’re new to Indian cooking and want easy tips on marinating different proteins, don’t miss our complete guide to marinades.

The Secret Behind Tender Butter Chicken

Yogurt-based marinade explained

If there’s one secret every cook should know about homemade butter chicken, it’s that yogurt is the key to tenderness. Unlike acidic marinades that can toughen meat, yogurt works gently. The lactic acid and enzymes in yogurt slowly break down chicken fibers, making the meat incredibly soft and juicy. It also forms a creamy coating that holds onto spices, ensuring every bite is flavorful.

When preparing your marinade, use plain full-fat yogurt for the best results. Low-fat or flavored yogurts don’t provide the same richness and may alter the taste of your butter chicken. To maximize flavor, combine yogurt with lemon juice, ginger-garlic paste, and a blend of aromatic spices. This not only tenderizes but also infuses the chicken with layers of flavor that carry through the entire dish.

Cooking techniques for juicy chicken

Even with the perfect marinade, cooking technique plays a huge role in achieving restaurant-style tenderness. Here are the most effective methods:

1. Grilling or Broiling: Gives the chicken a smoky, tandoor-like flavor, sealing in juices while adding a charred edge.
2. Pan-searing: Quick and convenient for home cooks, pan-searing locks in moisture before the chicken simmers in the sauce.
3. Oven-baking: A hands-off method that ensures even cooking and consistent texture.

No matter which method you choose, avoid overcooking the chicken. Butter chicken is best when the chicken is just cooked through and then finished gently in the sauce. Overcooking will make it tough, while simmering it too long in the sauce can strip away its smoky notes.

Pro tip: Slightly undercook the chicken before adding it to the sauce. It will finish cooking as it absorbs the buttery tomato base, staying moist and tender.

For even more inspiration on cooking juicy family-style meals, check out our best cooking techniques collection.

Creating the Creamy Butter Chicken Sauce

Tomato base preparation for butter chicken

The heart of homemade butter chicken is its velvety tomato-based sauce. The trick lies in balancing acidity with sweetness to achieve that signature flavor. Traditionally, fresh ripe tomatoes are blanched, peeled, and pureed to create a smooth base. However, for convenience, canned tomato purée can also be used — just make sure it’s high quality without added preservatives.

The process usually begins with sautéing onions, garlic, and ginger in butter until golden and fragrant. Once softened, tomatoes are added and simmered until they break down into a thick, rich mixture. A pinch of sugar or honey is sometimes added to balance the tanginess of the tomatoes. Straining the sauce before adding cream ensures a silky-smooth texture, just like the kind you’d find in an Indian restaurant.

Adding cream, butter, and cashew paste

What sets butter chicken apart from other curries is its creamy finish. Heavy cream, butter, and ground cashews or almonds are blended into the tomato base, creating a luxurious, velvety sauce. Each element plays a role:

• Butter adds richness and depth.
• Cream balances spices and creates a silky mouthfeel.
• Cashew paste thickens the sauce naturally while enhancing its nutty undertone.

For a lighter version, you can substitute cream with coconut milk or half-and-half, though the flavor will shift slightly. Adding a final touch of crushed dried fenugreek leaves (Kasuri methi) before serving elevates the aroma and gives your homemade butter chicken that authentic restaurant-style finish.

If you’re curious about more creamy curry bases beyond butter chicken, don’t miss our authentic curry sauce recipes.

Homemade Butter Chicken Spice Mix

Common spices used in butter chicken masala

At the core of every delicious homemade butter chicken is the masala—or spice mix—that infuses it with warmth and complexity. While you can buy pre-made blends at the store, making your own spice mix at home gives you fresher, more vibrant flavors.

Here are the key spices commonly used in butter chicken masala:

• Coriander powder – adds mild sweetness with a citrusy note.
• Cumin powder – earthy, nutty, and slightly smoky.
• Turmeric – provides golden color and subtle warmth.
• Garam masala – a balanced blend of cardamom, cloves, and cinnamon.
• Red chili powder or paprika – controls the heat and adds color.
• Fenugreek leaves (Kasuri methi) – signature flavor of restaurant-style butter chicken.
• Black pepper – adds a sharp kick to balance the creaminess.

Together, these spices create the foundation for a flavorful sauce that clings beautifully to tender chicken pieces.

DIY spice blend recipe step-by-step

Making your own butter chicken spice mix is surprisingly simple and requires only a few minutes. Here’s a step-by-step guide to preparing a small batch you can store and use whenever you crave homemade butter chicken:

Homemade Butter Chicken Masala (Spice Mix)

Spice	Quantity
Coriander powder	3 tbsp
Cumin powder	2 tbsp
Turmeric	1 tsp
Red chili powder (or paprika)	1.5 tsp
Garam masala	2 tsp
Fenugreek leaves (Kasuri methi, crushed)	1 tbsp
Black pepper	½ tsp

Instructions:

1. Dry roast whole spices (if using cumin seeds, cardamom pods, or cloves) until aromatic.
2. Grind them into a fine powder using a spice grinder.
3. Mix with the remaining ground spices in a clean, dry bowl.
4. Store in an airtight glass jar for up to 2 months.

This DIY spice mix ensures every batch of butter chicken tastes authentic, flavorful, and fresher than using pre-ground store-bought blends. And the best part? You can tweak the quantities to suit your personal spice preference.

For more inspiration on homemade spice blends for curries, don’t miss our collection of DIY masala recipes.

Cooking Methods for Butter Chicken

Stovetop vs oven vs instant pot

Homemade butter chicken can be cooked in multiple ways, each delivering slightly different results. Choosing the right method depends on your time, kitchen tools, and flavor preferences.

1. Stovetop Cooking:
   • The most traditional method.
   • Chicken is pan-seared or grilled separately, then simmered in the buttery tomato sauce.
   • Offers the richest flavor and the closest match to restaurant-style butter chicken.
2. Oven-Baking:
   • Ideal if you want to reduce hands-on cooking time.
   • Marinated chicken can be baked until slightly charred, then added to the sauce.
   • Produces tender, evenly cooked chicken but with less smokiness than stovetop grilling.
3. Instant Pot/Pressure Cooker:
   • Great for busy families.
   • Chicken and sauce cook together in one pot, cutting cooking time nearly in half.
   • Flavors meld quickly, but you may need to sauté extra butter and cream at the end for the authentic finish.

Each method can yield mouthwatering results, but stovetop cooking remains the gold standard for capturing that deep, layered flavor.

Restaurant-style vs homemade adjustments

Restaurant butter chicken often tastes slightly different from homemade versions due to the use of commercial tandoors (clay ovens) and heavy cream in large quantities. But with a few adjustments, you can get very close at home:

• Smoky Flavor: Add a charred touch by grilling chicken on high heat or using smoked paprika in your spice mix.
• Extra Creaminess: Stir in a splash of cream right before serving for a luxurious finish.
• Balanced Spice: Keep the heat mild so the buttery tomato sauce stands out, but offer chili flakes on the side for spice lovers.

For families who want to master different cooking styles at home, don’t miss our easy family cooking methods guide.

Print

Serving and Pairing Ideas

Best sides: naan, rice, parathas

Homemade butter chicken is incredibly versatile, pairing beautifully with a range of sides that soak up its rich, creamy sauce. Some of the most popular accompaniments include:

• Naan bread: Soft, fluffy, and slightly charred naan is the ultimate partner for butter chicken. It’s perfect for scooping up every last drop of sauce.
• Steamed Basmati rice: Light and fragrant, basmati rice balances the richness of the curry, making it ideal for family-style meals.
• Jeera rice (cumin rice): Adds extra flavor without overpowering the butter chicken.
• Parathas or roti: A slightly crispy, layered flatbread that pairs beautifully with creamy curries.

For a full Indian-style feast, combine butter chicken with naan and rice — it’s a combination that never fails to impress.

Beverage pairings for butter chicken meals

Since butter chicken is rich and creamy, it pairs well with refreshing drinks that cleanse the palate. Some popular options include:

• Mango lassi: A sweet, cooling yogurt-based drink that complements spicy food.
• Masala chai: A spiced Indian tea that makes the meal feel even more authentic.
• Sparkling water or soda: Helps cut through the creaminess for a lighter dining experience.
• Light white wines (like Sauvignon Blanc): Their crisp acidity balances the buttery sauce.

For family dinners or gatherings, try setting up a mini “Indian thali” experience with butter chicken at the center, paired with sides, drinks, and maybe even a dessert like gulab jamun. Looking for inspiration? Try our Indian dinner menu ideas.

Tips, Variations, and Storage

Healthier variations of butter chicken

Homemade butter chicken is traditionally rich and creamy, but you can easily adapt it into a lighter, healthier version without sacrificing flavor. Here are a few smart swaps:

• Cream alternatives: Replace heavy cream with Greek yogurt, coconut milk, or cashew cream for a lighter finish.
• Cooking method: Bake or grill the chicken instead of pan-frying to cut down on added fats.
• Oil control: Use ghee (clarified butter) in moderation instead of regular butter for a more balanced fat profile.
• Lean meat: Use chicken breast instead of thighs for a lower-fat option.

These variations let you enjoy the comfort of homemade butter chicken while keeping it suitable for everyday meals.

Storing and reheating without losing flavor

Butter chicken actually tastes even better the next day, as the flavors continue to deepen overnight. To store and reheat it properly:

• Storage: Cool completely before transferring to an airtight container. Store in the refrigerator for up to 3–4 days.
• Freezing: Butter chicken freezes well for up to 2 months. Freeze in portion-sized containers to make reheating easier.
• Reheating: Warm gently on the stovetop over low heat. Add a splash of cream or milk to restore creaminess if the sauce thickens too much.
• Microwave option: Heat in short intervals, stirring often to avoid drying out the chicken.

Pro tip: Avoid reheating butter chicken multiple times — reheat only the portion you plan to serve. This helps preserve both taste and texture.

For more storage-friendly recipes your whole family will love, check out our meal prep ideas collection.

FAQs About Homemade Butter Chicken

What are the ingredients in butter chicken?

Butter chicken typically includes boneless chicken (preferably thighs), yogurt for marination, tomatoes, onions, garlic, ginger, butter, cream, and a variety of spices such as cumin, coriander, turmeric, garam masala, and red chili powder. A handful of dried fenugreek leaves (Kasuri methi) adds that signature restaurant-style aroma.

What is the secret to the tender butter chicken?

The secret lies in the yogurt-based marinade combined with the right cooking technique. Yogurt naturally tenderizes the chicken while infusing it with flavor. Slightly undercooking the chicken before adding it to the sauce also helps keep it juicy and moist.

What makes butter chicken so creamy?

The creaminess comes from a combination of heavy cream, butter, and ground cashew or almond paste. These ingredients create a silky, velvety texture that balances the spices and makes butter chicken stand out from other curries.

How to make butter chicken spice mix?

A basic homemade spice mix includes coriander, cumin, turmeric, red chili powder, garam masala, fenugreek leaves, and black pepper. Toasting and grinding the spices fresh brings out the deepest flavors. Store in an airtight jar and use it whenever you’re craving homemade butter chicken.

---

Conclusion

Quick recap of making homemade butter chicken

Homemade butter chicken is more than just a recipe — it’s a full culinary experience. From marinating chicken in yogurt and spices to crafting a rich tomato-based sauce enriched with cream, butter, and cashew paste, every step contributes to its irresistible taste.

Why this recipe will impress your family and guests

Cooking butter chicken at home gives you complete control over ingredients, spice levels, and creaminess, making it healthier and customizable. Whether you serve it with naan, basmati rice, or parathas, this dish is sure to bring smiles around the dinner table. Once you try making homemade butter chicken yourself, you’ll never look at takeout the same way again.

And if you’re looking for more comfort food recipes your family will love, don’t miss our top-rated family dinner ideas.

For daily recipes you can follow me on Facebook and Pinterest.